Saturday, 5 September 2026
← Back to latest stories

Controversy

Blake Lively and Justin Baldoni End Major Claims but Legal-Fee Dispute Continues

The central It Ends With Us litigation has been settled, but Blake Lively continued seeking legal fees connected to Justin Baldoni’s defamation action.

Blake Lively and Justin Baldoni End Major Claims but Legal-Fee Dispute Continues

Blake Lively and Justin Baldoni settled the remaining central claims arising from the production of It Ends With Us, avoiding a trial after a legal dispute that dominated Hollywood coverage for more than a year.

How the case developed

Lively alleged harassment and retaliation after raising concerns about Baldoni’s conduct on set. Baldoni denied wrongdoing and brought a $400 million defamation action involving Lively, Ryan Reynolds and others. Much of that countersuit was dismissed because statements made to a California civil-rights agency were protected.

Settlement did not end every issue

After key claims were resolved, Lively sought legal fees and additional relief under a California law designed to protect people who report alleged harassment from retaliatory defamation claims. Baldoni’s representatives said the outcome vindicated him and maintained that there had been no harassment or smear campaign.

A carefully divided outcome

Both sides publicly characterised parts of the result as victories. The settlement avoided a trial, but it did not produce a simple judicial finding that endorsed every allegation by either party.

The film earned more than $350 million worldwide despite the controversy.

Sources

About the author

Scandle Wire Desk

The Scandle Wire desk delivers independent summaries and analysis grounded in established reporting and primary sources.